All works on this site, unless otherwise noted, are copyrighted to the author Missy H. (aka M. Hull). Please do not use any posts without permission of blog author. You can contact me via email.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

Another Loss to Needlework and Stitchers

Many people believe that designers aren't affected very much by piracy of their charts. This is not true. In my last post I did some math with very basic numbers to show a few different things, one that cross stitch charts are reasonably priced and do not reflect the hours put into producing them, and two to show how much money is actually lost through theft of the charts.

Well a designer, Monique of My Mark designs, posted a blog entry where she did the math surrounding actual piracy of just one of her charts. I feel it is quite an eye opener if people actually read it. Her figures show a loss of over 800,000 dollars in a single year for the needlework industry. This loss takes into consideration 50 people providing a single chart which is normally priced at $7.00 and uses the actual number of downloads from a single person in one year (2,470). It is utterly amazing! I would say that $800,000 dollars is a MASSIVE loss to the needlework industry!

See for yourself how seriously stealing cross stitch charts does affect the needlework industry.Go here and read it:

Sadly another designer is closing her doors as a direct result of internet piracy crippling sales for her business. As of October 31, 2010 Lavender Wings will close and the charts will no longer be available for purchase. Ms. Hinckley makes it very clear on the first page of her website that internet piracy is the reason for closing her company. Her charts are beautiful and due to piracy the needlework industry is losing yet another wonderful designer. You can read her words here: 

Out of curiosity I started following the links that these thieves put in their emails to pirate groups. Each link leads to a blog or posting board that contains even more links. All of these links lead to yet another web site, posting board, email group, or blog that "shares" stolen charts for free. Thousands of people are doing this every day. The money lost has to be somewhere in the millions per year! These same people profess to love needlework yet they happily continue to steal charts and cripple the industry they say they love. To me, that is not love.

I have also noticed that not many people respond to posts about copyright infringement (either on blogs or facebook or emails). I hope that this does not mean that the majority of people do not care, but I suppose it could mean that. Heck, it could mean many different things. But if more people spoke out against copyright infringement, if more people notified designers when they find a site that steals charts, and if more people refused to share copies of charts then we could put a major dent in the number of thefts occurring every day. We can't keep waiting for "someone else" to work against piracy. It only takes a moment to fire off an email about a web site or email group that is sharing charts. That one moment could be the one that keeps a favorite designer from closing their doors and quitting.

This web page answers many of the common misconceptions about copyright of needlework and other craft patterns.

If we continue to turn a blind eye to piracy, and continue to think "someone else" will handle it, then we will continue to lose designers and the hobby we love so much will suffer.


  1. I never even thought of stealing a chart. I always make a point to buy from my local cross stitch store and if I can't get there, 123 stitch. I never knew there were such sites. I have never seen them, but then again I never googled to find stolen charts. Lavender wings is sad because they have beautiful charts. I had no idea this was a problem. How sad. The charts a cheap enough to begin with. Thanks for the eye opener.

  2. I think those numbers are really an exaggeration. People take things they can get for free that they would not necessarily buy if they couldn't get them for free. I suspect the real problem is a declining interest in cross stitch, a great abundance of new designers since getting into the game via on-line sales is easier than ever, lots of legitimate freebies on the internet, and the legitimate free secondary market for charts (e-bay, etc).

  3. I have read about this problem, and realized that it was a big problem, but I had no idea how costly it is to the needlework industry. After reading this I have to wonder how someone could enjoy a piece of stitching in their home knowing it was stolen. I do hope that the right people read your post and this piracy of needlework charts can come to a halt. It's sad that yet another designer is retiring from this.

  4. Between one and the other, quite a few desingers are closing down, yet many more open their business.
    Let's hope those new ones stay on for a long time.
    I had never heard of Lavender Wings, but her segins are quite lovely. Thanks for sharing!

  5. I am still always amazed by this...I do not understand...I go through great lengths to get my charts and legitimately...I spent a few months looking for a JCS issue, because even Hoffman publishers had sold out of this issue and had no backcopies...
    With all the freebies that are out there...honestly, there is NO reason for this...I would rather pay a few bucks to keep these designers designing...It is worth it to me...I just have to save for it a bit more (like I've paid a bit for Renalto Parolin Charts...but it was worth it).

  6. It is disgusting what is happening and I, for one, would much rather buy a chart I really want than steal it. If I can't afford it I'll do without, save up for it, or ask a family member to buy me it for my birthday or Christmas. I wish these people would realise that, in the long run, everybody who does this hobby will suffer because there will be no designers left out there.


Thank you very much for visiting my internet home for my crafts. I appreciate your taking the time to visit and/or comment.

If you have any questions (looking for designer information of a piece I'm stitching, how to do cross stitch etc. ) please feel free to contact me. You will find my email address in my profile and I will do my best to either answer your question, or find information that can help you get your answer.

Thank you again for the visit and I hope you have a great day!

Missy (aka Raven)